Each week, we share an applied tip or did-you-know to help you build knowledge and hone essential skills that help you kick butt at work and in life.
Overcoming Decision Fatigue
Sometimes, after a long day, my partner will ask me what I want for dinner, and I would rather burn the house down than make that decision. When you’re making 35,000 decisions a day, even something as simple as choosing dinner can be challenging. Decision fatigue impacts us all, and as a leader, it can significantly affect productivity and effectiveness. Let’s talk about what it is, how it affects us, and strategies for overcoming it.
What is Decision Fatigue?
Decision fatigue is the mental exhaustion that results from the sheer number of decisions we make daily. From trivial choices like what to wear to critical business decisions, our brains can only handle so much. Research shows that our decision-making ability deteriorates after making numerous decisions, leading to safer or more impulsive choices or even decision paralysis.
One study found that patients who saw surgeons toward the end of the surgeon’s work shift were less likely to be scheduled for an operation—a decision that could have significant implications for the patient’s outcomes. Another found that judges are less likely to grant parole later in the day. When we're battling decision fatigue, we are more likely to default to the easiest—but not necessarily the best—option.
That’s why it’s critical to identify and counteract it.
Identifying Decision Fatigue
Recognizing decision fatigue is the first step toward managing it. Common signs include procrastination, feeling overwhelmed, and making impulsive decisions. If you notice that you’re struggling to make choices you usually find easy, it might be time to take a step back.
Ask yourself these questions:
- Do you often feel mentally drained by the end of the day?
- Are you procrastinating more than usual?
- Do you make snap decisions just to get things over with?
- Have you felt overwhelmed by choices, even small ones?
If you answered “yes” to any of these, you might be experiencing decision fatigue.
Strategies for Overcoming Decision Fatigue
Recognizing decision fatigue is the first step, but knowing how to combat it is essential for maintaining effectiveness. Here are some practical strategies to help you overcome decision fatigue and make smarter choices:
Prioritize
Not all decisions are created equal. Focusing on the most critical decisions conserves mental energy. A classic example is President Obama, who famously only wore blue or gray suits during his presidency to reduce the number of decisions he had to make daily. This strategy helped him conserve his stamina for more significant decisions.
Don’t know how to start? Use the Eisenhower Matrix to help categorize decisions by urgency and importance.
Delegate
Effective leaders know the power of delegation. By entrusting your team with decisions, you reduce your cognitive load and empower them. Ask yourself: What tasks am I uniquely qualified for? What work is worth my “hourly rate?” Focus on that and delegate the rest.
When delegating, be clear on expectations. Spend extra time in the hand-off to ensure everyone is on the same page. Communicate the goal and intended outcome, but resist mandating a specific process. Trust your team and avoid micromanaging.
Create Routines
Routines can significantly reduce the number of decisions you need to make daily. By automating mundane choices—like planning your meals for the week, time-blocking your calendar, or sticking to a consistent morning routine—you save your mental energy for more important decisions.
Just understand that developing (and sticking to) habits and routines can take time and be an energy expender in and of itself. Get clear on your internal motivation, set the bar at a reasonable height to begin, and adjust as needed.
Use a Decision-making Framework
Using structured frameworks can make complex decisions more manageable and offer a clear path forward. Sometimes, big decisions can feel like a swirling mess in your head, especially after making 34,999 other decisions. But frameworks like pros and cons lists, decision trees, or weighted decision matrices simplify the decision-making process by breaking it down into manageable steps.
Engage in Self-care
Taking care of your mental health is crucial in maintaining decision-making capacity. Regular breaks throughout the day prevent burnout and keep your mind fresh, allowing you to return to tasks with renewed focus. Mindfulness practices, such as meditation or deep-breathing exercises, help reduce stress and improve concentration, making it easier to handle decision-making pressures. Physical exercise, whether it's a quick walk around the block or a session at the gym, boosts endorphins and enhances cognitive function, providing a mental reset. Additionally, ensuring adequate sleep and a balanced diet supports overall brain health, enabling you to tackle decisions with clarity and confidence. By prioritizing self-care, you can sustain your decision-making abilities and maintain a high level of performance in your leadership role.
Create a Decision-friendly Culture
Creating a supportive organizational culture can significantly mitigate decision fatigue for everyone involved and there are plenty of ways to support decision-making with team-wide practices and policies. For example, implementing flexible work hours can help reduce stress by allowing employees to work when they feel most productive. Creating open communication channels enables team members to share decision-making burdens, ensuring that no single person is overwhelmed. You might even introduce decision-free days to provide a much-needed mental recharge, giving employees the space to focus on fun, easy, or less critical tasks—whatever reduces the decision-making load!
A Final Thought
Mastering the art of decision-making isn't just about productivity—it's about reclaiming your mental bandwidth and enhancing your leadership capacity. As you implement these strategies, you'll likely notice a ripple effect. Your improved decision-making will influence your team's performance, fostering a culture of thoughtful choices and strategic thinking. The goal isn't necessarily to eliminate all decision-making stress—some tension is natural and even beneficial in leadership roles. Instead, aim to create a sustainable approach that allows you to navigate complex choices with clarity and confidence.
And simple ones without burning the house down.